Why Your God Doesn't Exist

Stolen in full from Rosa Rubicondior:

It's quite easy to prove logically that your god doesn't exist.

The proof is a simple deduction from certain basic assumptions which themselves are only assumptions in the sense of assuming the description you use for your god is true in the first instance. It goes without saying that if your description of your god is false then the god you are describing is also false.

Let's assume your god is real and has the following notional characteristics.

God is:

  • Omnipotent – all powerful – there is nothing your god can't do.
  • Omniscient – all knowing – there is nothing your god doesn't know.
  • Omni-benevolent – all-loving – there is nothing your god wouldn't do to defend and protect its creation.

Okay so far? Is there anything you disagree with here? Is there something your god can't do if it has a mind to? Is there anything your god doesn't know? How about all loving? Is there anything or anyone your god doesn't love and for whom it has anything less than the greatest possible concern?

And yet we can see suffering exists.

For suffering to exist, your god must be deficient in at least one of the above. At least one of the following must be true. God is:

  • Unable to prevent it, so it isn't omnipotent.
  • Unaware of it, so it isn't omniscient.
  • Unconcerned about it, so it isn't all-loving

So, the existence of suffering in the world proves your god as described above does not exist.

Strange then that so much of your time is spent asking your god to either stop, reduce or prevent suffering, which is nothing more than tacit acceptance that an omniscience, omnipotent, omni-benevolent god doesn't exist.

Of course, you can escape the above logic by saying your god isn't omnipotent, isn't omniscience and/or isn't omni-benevolent, but a god who can't change things, doesn't know when they need to be changed and/or isn't bothered anyway isn't much of a god and certainly not one worthy of worship. In fact, it's hard to imagine how we could distinguish such a god from a non-existent one.

I love these simple little proofs that gods don't exist. They are so much more elegant and simple than the cumbersome, convoluted and illogical 'proofs' which religious apologists have to try to get away with. That's the great thing about being supported by evidence, reason, logic and truth, and so not needing to fall back on the fallacy of faith and having to employ charlatans to make you feel better about being superstitious.

One Reply to “Why Your God Doesn't Exist”

  1. They'd probably balk at "omni-benevolent," saying God doesn't love everything, blah, blah. But they DO often say "God is love," which is pretty much the same thing. The main problem is, religious people (and I mean the in-your-face, I love, love, love Jesus variety) they are absolutely impervious to logic and reason. The easy answers to this puzzle–as they would see it–is that "the lord works in mysterious ways," or "that hasn't been revealed to us yet," or that we wretched sinners are incapable of seeing "God's plan." With that, and "god worked a magic trick," they've got all the bases covered.

Comments are closed.